How we see ourselves is shaped in the mind, not in the mirror
Kinga Bigaj
Appearance is widely discussed today, usually in the context of the media and self-acceptance. Less attention is paid to the fact that, alongside the image we see in the mirror, each of us carries a mental picture of our own appearance. Psychology has long shown that this image can influence how we judge ourselves, how we interpret other people's behaviour and even how our relationships unfold.
The Mirror That Makes Us Look Better
Do we really know what we look like? Nicholas Epley and Erin Whitchurch decided to find out. They photographed participants and then digitally blended their photographs with faces that had been rated as either more or less attractive. This produced several versions of the same face, each differing in the degree of enhancement. Participants were asked to identify the version that looked most like them. They were more likely to choose a slightly enhanced version, shifted by a few to just over ten per cent towards a more attractive appearance. A similar effect was also found when participants were asked to recognise the face of a close friend, but it was not observed when they were shown the face of someone relatively unfamiliar [1. Epley, Whitchurch, 2008].
The study focused on faces rather than the body as a whole, but it clearly shows that our mental image of our appearance does not necessarily reflect reality accurately. This does not mean, however, that everyone sees themselves as more attractive than they really are. For some people, their mental image of their appearance can be much harsher. Rather than boosting their confidence, it becomes a source of tension and emotional distress. Perhaps this is why reassurances such as "You really do look good" so rarely help. The person offering reassurance has in mind the face they see with their own eyes, while the person hearing it is thinking of the face they carry in their mind.
A Spotlight That Isn't There
In another study, Thomas Gilovich and his colleagues asked students to put on a T-shirt featuring a picture of Barry Manilow, which they believed might be embarrassing, and briefly enter a room full of their peers. The students predicted that roughly half of the people in the room would recognise the person pictured on their T-shirt. In reality, far fewer did. The researchers called this the spotlight effect: we overestimate how much attention other people pay to our appearance and behaviour [2. Gilovich et al., 2000].
Something similar happens with our appearance in everyday life. A bad hair day, reddened skin or a few extra kilos can seem obvious to us, as though everyone could spot them from a distance. Other people do pay attention to appearance, of course, but usually far less than we imagine. Most people are simply busy thinking about themselves.
The Scar That Wasn't There
A surprising study was conducted in 1980 by Robert Kleck and Angelo Strenta. They wanted to find out how the belief that we have a physical feature others might judge negatively affects the way we interpret other people's behaviour.
In one version of the experiment, the researchers applied a realistic-looking, healed scar to the participants' faces. They were given a mirror so they could examine it closely. The researcher then told them that he would apply a moisturising cream to prevent the makeup from cracking and flaking. In reality, he used this step to remove the scar without telling the participants.
The women believed that the scar was still visible. They then spoke for approximately six minutes with another woman who knew nothing about the experiment or the earlier makeup application. In fact, they were talking to someone who could not see any scar on their faces.
After the conversation, the participants assessed their conversation partners' behaviour and then watched a recording of their interaction. The women who believed they still had a visible scar rated their conversation partners as more tense and thought that the other women had found them less attractive. Particularly interesting, however, was what they focused on while watching the recording. They paid more attention to the other women's glances and interpreted them as reactions to their appearance.
Independent observers who assessed the recordings, however, found no differences in the conversation partners' behaviour between the experimental conditions. The participants were therefore interpreting other people's behaviour through the belief that their appearance might provoke a negative reaction, even though the women they spoke to had not seen any scar [3. Kleck, Strenta, 1980].
Simply believing that the scar was still there was enough to make an ordinary glance from another person seem like a reaction to it. This shows how easily our ideas about what other people see when they look at us can influence the way we interpret their behaviour.
A Conversation Over the Phone
Mark Snyder, Elizabeth Tanke and Ellen Berscheid explored what happens when other people hold particular beliefs about our appearance. Men were asked to have telephone conversations with women they had never met. Before each conversation, the men were given a photograph of the woman they were supposedly about to speak to. In reality, the photograph showed a different woman, who was either considered attractive or less attractive. The women had no idea which photograph their conversation partners had been shown.
The men who believed they were speaking to an attractive woman behaved more naturally and sociably during the conversation. The women responded to the way they were treated, and their behaviour was later rated by independent observers as friendlier and more sociable. The observers listened to recordings containing only the women's voices, without knowing what expectations the men had started with. The women therefore began to behave in ways that matched their conversation partners' expectations [4. Snyder et al., 1977].
Psychologists call this a self-fulfilling prophecy. Our beliefs can influence the way we treat another person, and that person's response can, in turn, confirm our original expectations.
What Can We Take Away From This?
The studies described above illustrate several different but related phenomena. Our mental image of our appearance does not always match what other people see. We may overestimate how much attention they pay to the way we look, interpret ambiguous signals as signs of negative judgement, and allow our expectations to influence our interactions with others.
It is worth remembering, however, that not every fear of being judged is unfounded. Judgement and discrimination based on appearance are real and should not be dismissed. Still, not every reaction from another person is a comment about us. Sometimes a glance, gesture or silence has an entirely different explanation from the one suggested by our own fears.
The next time we feel that someone has given us a disapproving look, it may be worth asking ourselves a few questions. Was it really about my appearance? Did that person even notice it, or were they simply preoccupied with their own thoughts? Am I looking for confirmation of something I am afraid of? And could my own tension have influenced the course of the conversation?
One of the aims of the SOLIDA Foundation is to promote psychoeducation and support mental health. When thoughts about appearance become persistent, interfere with our enjoyment of life or begin to affect eating habits, sleep or relationships, it is worth discussing them with a psychologist or psychotherapist.
References
1. Epley, N., Whitchurch, E. (2008). Mirror, mirror on the wall: Enhancement in self-recognition. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 34(9), 1159–1170. https://doi.org/10.1177/0146167208318601
2. Gilovich, T., Medvec, V. H., Savitsky, K. (2000). The spotlight effect in social judgment: An egocentric bias in estimates of the salience of one's own actions and appearance. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 78(2), 211–222. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.78.2.211
3. Kleck, R. E., Strenta, A. (1980). Perceptions of the impact of negatively valued physical characteristics on social interaction. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 39(5), 861–873. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.39.5.861
4. Snyder, M., Tanke, E. D., Berscheid, E. (1977). Social perception and interpersonal behavior: On the self-fulfilling nature of social stereotypes. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 35(9), 656–666. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.35.9.656