Defensive Responses and Dissociative Experiences Under Conditions of Chronic Uncertainty

Kinga Bigaj, Katarzyna Leszczyńska

Abstract

Chronic, unresolved uncertainty associated with geopolitical threats constitutes a particular context for psychological functioning. For people living in Poland, this context has involved the war in Ukraine since February 2022 and the uncertainty surrounding its possible developments. Prolonged uncertainty differs from an acute response to a single traumatic event and may influence how a person responds to potential threat.

In threatening situations, the organism activates automatic defensive responses, including arousal, fight or flight, freezing, and tonic immobility, encompassing a broad spectrum of responses to extreme stress (Bracha, 2004), which do not form a single rigid sequence (Kozlowska et al., 2015). Dissociation, by contrast, is a distinct construct referring, among other things, to changes in the integration of consciousness, memory, and the sense of continuity of self. It may occur alongside defensive responses, but it is not their automatic consequence.

This article organizes these concepts and proposes a framework for clinical observation that may help distinguish transient reactions from experiences requiring more in depth specialist assessment. The framework is conceptual rather than diagnostic, and the relationship between chronic uncertainty and dissociation remains a theoretical hypothesis rather than an empirically established causal association.

Keywords: dissociation, freezing, tonic immobility, defensive responses, chronic uncertainty, trauma, mental health in crisis, intolerance of uncertainty

1. Introduction and Aim

Geopolitical threats with unpredictable trajectories and no clear point of resolution constitute a specific psychological challenge, including for people who are not directly affected by them but remain within the range of their potential consequences. Since February 2022, people living in Poland have been functioning under conditions of prolonged uncertainty concerning the development of the war in Ukraine and its possible consequences. The impact of this situation on the psychological well being of people not directly involved in the conflict has been one of the less frequently discussed topics in the mental health debate.

A study conducted by a team from SWPS University found that, despite Poland not being directly involved in military operations, 57.2% of Polish respondents, among more than 1,600 participants from Poland, Ukraine, and Taiwan, exceeded the threshold indicating elevated symptoms of posttraumatic stress (Chudzicka Czupała et al., 2023). The sample was not representative of the national population. A subsequent study by the same team (Chudzicka Czupała et al., 2025) showed that these differences could not be explained by geographic proximity to the conflict alone: Polish students reported higher levels of depression and stress than their Ukrainian peers despite having less direct experience of war, while problem focused coping emerged as a key factor differentiating the groups.

It should be emphasized, however, that the cited studies primarily concern anxiety, depression, posttraumatic stress symptoms, and coping strategies rather than direct measurement of dissociation. These data illustrate the scale of the psychological burden associated with the war and the uncertainty accompanying it, but they do not in themselves support an inference of a direct causal relationship between this burden and the occurrence of dissociative episodes. This psychological situation therefore differs from a single, time limited traumatic event, and the defensive responses that may become activated in this context require separate clinical consideration.

The aim of this article is to organize concepts related to freezing, tonic immobility, and dissociation and to propose a practical framework for clinical observation that can help structure observations of reactions and identify situations in which more in depth specialist assessment may be warranted. The aim of the paper is not to systematically evaluate effectiveness or compare theoretical models, but to integrate them for the purposes of clinical differentiation between defensive responses and dissociative experiences in the context of chronic uncertainty. Particular importance is placed on distinguishing automatic defensive responses from dissociative experiences, as well as transient reactions from symptoms that persist and affect functioning.

2. Theoretical Frameworks

2.1. The Defense Cascade: Arousal, Freezing, and Tonic Immobility

The defense cascade is an evolutionarily shaped set of survival responses. In response to threat, extensive neural networks are engaged, including the amygdala, hypothalamus, periaqueductal gray, as well as structures of the brainstem and autonomic nervous system. Depending on the nature of the threat and the possibility of escaping it, the organism may activate different defensive responses, ranging from mobilization for action to responses that restrict movement and activity.

The first stage is arousal, during which the organism registers a threat and mobilizes physiological resources. It involves awareness of threat, threat appraisal processes, and increased physiological arousal, including an increased heart rate. When fight or flight is possible, arousal may progress to the next stage of the cascade, an active fight or flight response, in which the organism takes direct action toward the threat. The activity of particular brain structures at both stages depends on the type, intensity, and context of the threat.

Freezing may occur in situations of high threat, especially when action is difficult or risky, or when the situation requires a temporary cessation of activity in order to orient to the environment. It does not necessarily occur only when fight or flight are objectively impossible. One function attributed to this response from an evolutionary perspective is reducing detectability by a potential threat. The precise neurophysiological mechanism underlying this stage remains debated in the literature and should not be presented as definitively established.

Tonic immobility is another possible state within the defense cascade and is usually associated with a high level of threat and an inability to escape effectively, for example during a physical attack, sexual violence, or a brutal assault. A person may experience substantial restriction or a subjective inability to move, often while remaining conscious, and this is usually accompanied by pronounced muscular tension. It may also be accompanied by a sense of unreality or temporary inability to speak. In some cases, reduced pain perception also occurs, referred to as stress induced analgesia. A distinct and more extreme state described within the defense cascade is collapsed immobility, in which muscle tone decreases. This should not be equated with tonic immobility. From an evolutionary perspective, these responses are interpreted as defensive mechanisms that may increase the chances of survival under extreme threat, although their function cannot be reduced to a single simple purpose.

The defense cascade model should not be treated as a rigid sequence through which every person passes in the same order when faced with threat. It is better understood as a set of available responses whose course depends on multiple factors, such as the characteristics of a particular situation, perceived agency, personal resources including physical strength, and previous experiences. Dissociative experiences may occur alongside some of these states, particularly tonic immobility, but they do not constitute a simple next stage in the defense cascade model (Kozlowska et al., 2015). Research also indicates that peritraumatic tonic immobility is associated with greater posttraumatic stress symptoms, highlighting its clinical significance (Coimbra et al., 2023).

2.2. Dissociation as a Distinct Construct

Dissociation is a psychological and clinical phenomenon involving weakened integration between mental functions that normally operate coherently and are interconnected, such as memory, consciousness, identity, motor control, or perception. It is associated with specific neurobiological correlates, although the mechanisms underlying it are not yet fully understood. Manifestations of dissociation are diverse and do not have to involve all of these domains simultaneously. According to the DSM 5 TR, dissociation involves disruption or discontinuity in the normal integration of consciousness, memory, identity, emotion, perception, body representation, motor control, and behavior (American Psychiatric Association, 2022).

In some theoretical approaches, extreme overload or a sense of being unable to act effectively in response to threat may be associated with partial weakening of the integration of experience, described as a mechanism with a potentially protective function.

During ordinary day to day functioning, perceptual experience, such as “I perceive the situation in a particular way,” affective experience, such as “I feel joy, fear, or anger,” bodily experience, such as an accelerated heartbeat or shallow breathing, and memory, including the ability to register an event within the timeline of one’s life and locate it in a particular time, are usually integrated to a considerable degree.

In dissociative experience, the integration between these functions becomes weakened or partially disrupted, to varying degrees and on varying scales. A person experiencing dissociation may feel that they are seeing themselves from another person’s perspective or may observe an overwhelming or traumatic event without experiencing any emotions.

2.3. The Dissociative Continuum

In some theoretical approaches, dissociation is described more in terms of a spectrum of varying intensity than as an all or nothing phenomenon.

At the milder end of the continuum may be experiences such as attentional absorption or the brief sense of carrying out a familiar activity in a partly automatic manner, for example while driving a car along a familiar route. Not every such experience is considered dissociative, however, and the automation of well learned activities or brief mind wandering is not in itself equivalent to clinical dissociation.

Derealization and depersonalization are experiences that may vary in intensity from mild to severe. Derealization refers to a state in which the surrounding world seems unreal, as if seen “through glass.” Depersonalization refers to a sense of detachment from or unfamiliarity with one’s own body, thoughts, feelings, or sense of self. These states may be brief and transient or may persist for longer periods.

2.4. Neurobiological Basis and the Window of Tolerance

Specific neurobiological correlates have been described in dissociation, although their patterns vary according to the type of dissociation, the research method, and the context, and cannot be reduced to one universal mechanism. Within the defense cascade described by Kozlowska and colleagues (2015), freezing and tonic immobility may be accompanied by changes in autonomic nervous system activity, including both decreases and increases in heart rate, as well as reduced responsiveness to sensory stimuli and pain, although the extent and direction of these changes vary. More detailed neurobiological mechanisms underlying dissociation itself remain the subject of separate research and are beyond the scope of this article.

The concept of the window of tolerance, popularized in the clinical literature, among others, by Siegel (1999), is widely used in clinical practice. It describes a range of physiological and emotional arousal within which a person retains the ability to function flexibly and in an integrated manner: they can think, regulate emotions, and respond appropriately to the situation. Moving above the upper boundary of this range is usually associated with hyperarousal, including anxiety, irritability, and a sense of being overwhelmed, whereas moving below the lower boundary may be associated with hypoarousal symptoms such as slowing, withdrawal, or a sense of numbness. In the clinical literature, this state is also sometimes associated with certain dissociative experiences and immobilization responses.

The width of this range is not fixed and, as an interpretive application of the concept to the context under discussion rather than as a direct conclusion from Siegel’s work, may narrow under the influence of chronic stress or prolonged uncertainty. As a result, reactions that previously remained within the boundaries of flexible functioning may begin to exceed them in response to stimuli of lower intensity than before. The concept is primarily of heuristic and clinical value, helping to facilitate discussion of arousal regulation, but it is not a validated measurement tool.

2.5. The Specific Nature of Responses to Chronic, Unresolved Uncertainty

The model of generalized anxiety disorder proposed by Dugas, Gagnon, Ladouceur, and Freeston (1998) identifies intolerance of uncertainty as one of its central components, alongside such factors as positive beliefs about worry, negative problem orientation, and cognitive avoidance. Intolerance of uncertainty is described as a cognitive disposition involving the experience of ambiguous situations as threatening. Later developments of the construct emphasize that this may occur regardless of the actual probability of a negative event and describe it in terms including the belief that uncertainty is dangerous, unfair, and deprives a person of a sense of control, as well as difficulty tolerating a lack of information and a strong need for certainty. It is also associated with a tendency to worry, which together may promote negative appraisal of problematic situations and their perception as a threat or as confirmation of one’s own incompetence.

Later literature developing this model has also identified additional attempts to cope with uncertainty, including cognitive or behavioral avoidance, continual seeking of reassurance and confirmation from others, and procrastination, meaning the postponement of decisions or actions.

These mechanisms illustrate how negative beliefs about uncertainty and the behaviors aimed at reducing it may contribute to the maintenance of elevated arousal, although the model proposed by Dugas and colleagues (1998) does not directly describe the neurophysiological mechanisms of arousal in the nervous system. The greater a person’s tolerance of uncertainty, and therefore the lower their intolerance of uncertainty, the easier it may be to tolerate a state of suspension and act despite incomplete information.

3. A Framework for Clinical Observation

The models presented above do not provide a ready made tool that would automatically distinguish a transient reaction from an experience requiring more in depth assessment. On the basis of the literature discussed, the authors propose an original six dimensional framework for clinical observation, which does not constitute a validated research model.

Duration

A brief episode that subsides as the intensity of the stimulus decreases or the situation ends may be transient in nature. Greater attention is warranted when an experience persists despite the absence of an immediate threat, recurs, or becomes more intense over time.

Impact on Functioning

It is important to consider whether a person can continue to work, study, manage everyday responsibilities, and maintain relationships. Persistent disruption of these areas increases the need for further assessment.

Continuity of Memory and Sense of Self

The occurrence of repeated memory gaps, a sense of loss of continuity in one’s own experience, or difficulty reconstructing important parts of an event is clinically relevant. Temporary difficulty concentrating alone is not sufficient to identify dissociation.

Return to the Typical Level of Functioning

It is useful to observe whether the experience subsides and whether the person returns to their typical level of functioning. Particular attention is warranted when symptoms persist after the triggering situation has ended or occur with increasing frequency.

Relationship to the Situation or Its Reminder

A strong reaction may be associated with a specific stimulus, memory, or association and does not in itself have to indicate a disorder. Greater attention is warranted when intense experiences occur frequently without an identifiable connection to a situation and interfere with everyday functioning.

Impact on Relationships and Development

What matters is not only an individual episode but also its long term consequences. Progressive withdrawal from relationships, reduced activity, deterioration in occupational or educational functioning, and loss of a previous level of engagement may indicate a need for further assessment.

The areas described above are not diagnostic criteria. They should be considered together and in relation to the individual context of the person.

4. Practical Implications

In practice, it is important to avoid both minimizing transient reactions and pathologizing every experience of detachment or temporary absence. A single experience, by itself, does not make it possible to determine its clinical significance.

It is more useful to assess the dynamics of an experience than to evaluate a single behavior: its duration, frequency, impact on everyday functioning, continuity of memory, and the person’s ability to return to their typical level of activity. When experiences persist, intensify, significantly restrict functioning, or are associated with repeated memory gaps or a marked disruption in the continuity of one’s experience of self, consultation with a specialist is indicated.

For people requiring additional support, observed changes in behavior and functioning may become more important, particularly when communicating one’s internal state is difficult. However, not every change in concentration, withdrawal, or slowing should be equated with dissociation, because similar symptoms may have many other causes.

5. Limitations

This article is conceptual in nature and is based on selected theoretical and clinical literature. It is a narrative review rather than a systematic review.

The literature used in preparing this paper did not identify Polish studies directly measuring the severity of dissociative experiences in the context of chronic uncertainty related to the war in Ukraine. Available Polish studies have focused primarily on anxiety, depression, posttraumatic stress, and coping strategies (Chudzicka Czupała et al., 2023, 2025).

The relationship between chronic uncertainty and dissociation therefore remains a hypothesis requiring further empirical verification. The individual models used in this article have different levels of empirical support and should not be treated as equivalent in terms of evidential strength.

6. Conclusion

Chronic, unresolved uncertainty associated with the geopolitical situation constitutes a particular psychological context that differs from a single traumatic event. In response to threat, automatic defensive responses may occur, including freezing and tonic immobility, neither of which in itself indicates a disorder. Dissociation is a distinct construct involving, among other things, the integration of consciousness, memory, and the experience of self, and therefore should not automatically be equated with an immobilization response.

In clinical assessment, the most important considerations include the duration of the experience, its impact on functioning, continuity of memory and experience of self, the ability to return to a typical level of functioning, its relationship to the situation, and its long term impact on relationships and development. The proposed framework is intended to help structure observation and identify situations in which further specialist consultation may be warranted, without pathologizing transient reactions to chronic uncertainty.

References

American Psychiatric Association. (2022). *Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders* (5th ed., text rev., DSM 5 TR). Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Association Publishing.


Bracha, H. S. (2004). Freeze, flight, fight, fright, faint: Adaptationist perspectives on the acute stress response spectrum. *CNS Spectrums, 9*(9), 679 to 685. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1092852900001954


Chudzicka Czupała, A., Hapon, N., Chiang, S. K., Żywiołek Szeja, M., Karamushka, L., Lee, C. T., Grabowski, D., Paliga, M., Rosenblat, J. D., Ho, R., McIntyre, R. S., Chen, Y. L. (2023). Depression, anxiety and post traumatic stress during the 2022 Russo Ukrainian war, a comparison between populations in Poland, Ukraine, and Taiwan. *Scientific Reports, 13*, 3602. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598 023 28729 3


Chudzicka Czupała, A., Hao, F., Hapon, N., Dubniak, Z., Różycka, W., Ostafińska Molik, B., Ho, R. (2025). Well being of Ukrainian and Polish college students during the Russo Ukrainian war and coping strategies as predictors of mental health disorders. *Critical Public Health, 35*(1), 2460996. https://doi.org/10.1080/09581596.2025.2460996


Coimbra, B. M., Hoeboer, C. M., van Zuiden, M., Williamson, R. E., D’Elia, A. T., Mello, A. F., Mello, M. F., Olff, M. (2023). The relationship between tonic immobility and the development, severity, and course of posttraumatic stress disorder: Systematic and meta analytic literature review. *Journal of Anxiety Disorders, 97*, 102730. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.janxdis.2023.102730


Dugas, M. J., Gagnon, F., Ladouceur, R., Freeston, M. H. (1998). Generalized anxiety disorder: A preliminary test of a conceptual model. *Behaviour Research and Therapy, 36*, 215 to 226. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0005 7967(97)00070 3


Kozlowska, K., Walker, P., McLean, L., Carrive, P. (2015). Fear and the defense cascade: Clinical implications and management. *Harvard Review of Psychiatry, 23*(4), 263 to 287. https://doi.org/10.1097/HRP.0000000000000065


Siegel, D. J. (1999). *The Developing Mind: Toward a Neurobiology of Interpersonal Experience*. New York: Guilford Press.