Before We Had the Words to Make Sense of Terror
Kinga Bigaj
History is more interesting than a simple division between the world “before therapy” and the world “after therapy.” Long before modern psychology emerged, people already had their own ways of dealing with experiences they could neither easily name nor explain. They created rituals, stories, and myths. Later psychological and psychoanalytic theories did not necessarily have to invent these ways of coping from scratch. In many cases, they simply gave language to something people had been trying to do intuitively for a very long time.
An Experience the Mind Could Not Integrate
Before Freud began writing about the unconscious, the French psychiatrist Pierre Janet, working in the late nineteenth century with women who were then diagnosed with hysteria, systematically described dissociation. He observed that an experience exceeding the mind’s capacity to process it is not always integrated into the rest of memory and consciousness.
From this perspective, a traumatic experience did not necessarily have to be accessible as a coherent autobiographical memory. Instead, it could manifest through sensory experiences, affective states, or recurring patterns of behavior.
It is important, however, not to confuse two different phenomena. Janet’s concept of dissociation and the freeze response in the context of acute danger are not the same thing. Freezing describes an organism’s defensive response to threat, whereas dissociation, in the Janetian sense, refers to a disruption in the integration of aspects of psychological experience that may involve consciousness, memory, perception, and action. They can occur at the same time, but they do not mean the same thing.
Both phenomena can nevertheless emerge in situations in which an experience exceeds the psychological capacity available at that particular moment to process and integrate it. A bodily response arising in the face of danger does not necessarily involve conscious choice. It may be the organism’s way of coping with a situation that exceeds its current capacities.
The Mind as a Container
Several decades later, the British psychoanalyst Wilfred Bion began exploring a related but distinct problem: how emotional experience becomes something that can be thought about.
Bion described this process in terms of alpha function. In his theory, alpha function transforms beta elements, meaning unprocessed elements of experience, into alpha elements that can be used in thinking, dreaming, and symbolization. Until this transformation takes place, experience may remain what Bion called “nameless dread”: anxiety without a graspable form or meaning.
As a young tank commander, Bion took part in the First World War, and he returned to his wartime experiences throughout his later theoretical work. This does not mean that his theory was a straightforward consequence of war trauma. His experiences on the battlefield later became an important point of reference in his thinking about how experience becomes something that can be thought about.
In this context, Bion used the concepts of the container and the contained. In their classical formulation, these concepts describe a situation in which a person is not yet able to process their emotional experience on their own and relies on the presence of another person: someone who can receive their anxiety without becoming overwhelmed by it, give it some form, and return it in a way that is more bearable. Over time, this function can become part of a person’s own capacity to regulate and make sense of experience.
From this perspective, a practical implication can be drawn for providing support during a crisis. A person experiencing acute stress does not always need an explanation first. A calm presence, a simple message, and one manageable next step may often be more useful.
Naming the God: Externalizing Fear
In ancient Greece, the word panikon, meaning something “belonging to Pan,” was associated with sudden, irrational fear attributed to the presence of the god Pan. In stories about Pan, such fear could spread suddenly among people or animals.
The story of Pan is a well documented part of the Greek tradition. What we can read into it psychologically today is already an interpretation.
From a contemporary perspective, the story can be understood as resembling the externalization and personification of fear. This is not a clinical example of projection or externalization, but rather a modern cultural interpretation: an internal and incomprehensible state was given an external cause and a recognizable form.
The Work of Mourning and Ritual as Its External Framework
In 1917, Freud published his essay “Mourning and Melancholia.” In it, he distinguished between two ways of responding to loss. He described mourning as a process in which the psyche gradually confronts the reality of loss and withdraws libido from the lost object, which, in his model, eventually allowed libido to be redirected toward other objects. In melancholia, a person generally knows whom they have lost but does not fully know what exactly they have lost in that relationship. The ego then identifies with the lost object, while ambivalent feelings toward the lost object, including hostility, are directed against the self within this model.
This distinction became an important starting point for later thinking about mourning and melancholia. It is not, however, a contemporary diagnostic model. Modern approaches to grief are more complex and do not assume that attachment to a deceased person must be withdrawn through a simple, linear process.
Across cultures, mourning rituals created frameworks in which loss could be experienced through particular norms, gestures, and ways of remembering: keeping vigil, remembering the deceased together, or following established ways of speaking about loss.
This does not mean that an ancient ritual was equivalent to modern therapy. One can nevertheless observe a similar function: an experience that is difficult to organize internally becomes partially organized through something that exists outside the individual.
Storytelling as an Alpha Function Performed by the Community
In many cultures, there were people whose role was to preserve and transmit communal stories. Collective memory could be passed on through narrative, song, and oral storytelling.
Research on written expression suggests that giving important experiences an organized narrative form can support their organization and the process of assigning meaning to them. A related element is used, among other approaches, in Narrative Exposure Therapy, in which the detailed retelling of traumatic experiences forms part of a structured exposure process. This does not mean, however, that ancient stories were historical precursors of this therapeutic approach.
Using Bion’s language as a contemporary metaphor, one might say that the storyteller helped the community do something with an experience that a single person might not have been able to bear alone. Experiences of war, famine, or disaster could be given the form of a myth, story, or song, allowing people to return to them and pass them on to subsequent generations.
The Ghost That Was Not Mourned
In the 1970s, French psychoanalysts Nicolas Abraham and Maria Torok distinguished between introjection as a process of working through loss and incorporation as a phantasmatic way of avoiding that process. In their model, introjection refers to a psychological process of working through loss in which the experience of loss is gradually put into words and incorporated into one’s own history. Incorporation, by contrast, is associated with a situation in which the loss cannot undergo such a process. Instead, the loss is denied, accompanied by a fantasy that the lost object has been entirely “swallowed” and preserved internally without being worked through.
In Abraham and Torok’s model, incorporation is associated with the formation of what is known as a crypt: a metaphorically understood, closed psychic space in which the lost object and the unspoken experience associated with it are preserved rather than subjected to the process of introjection. On the outside, a person in whom such a crypt has formed may continue to function normally.
The ghost is not the same thing as the crypt. In Abraham and Torok’s theory, the ghost refers to the transgenerational effects of an unspoken secret from a previous generation. In this conception, a child does not inherit the actual content of what a parent left unspoken. Instead, the child becomes entangled in a gap, silence, or distortion in family transmission, which may manifest through affects, symptoms, or behaviors whose source remains unrecognized by the person.
The concepts of the crypt and the ghost are theoretical models rooted in the psychoanalytic tradition, not empirically established mechanisms of transmission. The statement that a child inherits not a memory but a void is, in this context, a theoretical metaphor rather than a scientifically established process.
Collective Defense: The Myth That Protected Itself
A good example is London during the German air raids of 1940 and 1941. British planners and psychiatrists feared a major collapse in morale and a large number of psychiatric consequences of the bombing. These predictions did not materialize. Over time, the legend of the “Blitz spirit” emerged: an image of calm Londoners waiting out the air raids with cups of tea.
This does not mean, however, that the people of London were simply psychologically resilient. Historians have pointed out that some forms of anxiety may not have appeared in psychiatric statistics. The pressure to maintain morale may also have made it more difficult to express fear publicly. Tension could instead find an outlet through insomnia, somatic complaints, and other symptoms.
From a psychoanalytic perspective, this can be interpreted as an example of a collective norm that made it more difficult for anxiety to be expressed. If psychoanalytic language is used, this is closer to repression and isolation of affect than to splitting in the strict sense. This remains an interpretation, not an established fact about every London resident.
More interesting than the legend itself is the tension behind it. On the one hand, the narrative may have strengthened the sense that the community could survive the bombing. On the other hand, social pressure to remain calm may have made it harder to speak openly about genuine fear and exhaustion.
This tension remains relevant today. Psychological support should not be reduced to the message “be strong and do not show fear.” What is needed instead are concrete ways of coping with what is actually happening to a person.
Conclusion
Janet wrote about dissociation, Bion about how experience becomes thinkable, Freud about the work of mourning, and Abraham and Torok about what may remain after a loss that could not be fully experienced and put into words. The history of the Blitz, in turn, shows how a community may attempt to cope with anxiety through a particular social norm.
These are different concepts, and they do not describe one single underlying mechanism. Some are historical or theoretical in nature, while others draw on contemporary empirical research. They nevertheless touch on a similar question: what happens to an experience that a person cannot integrate, name, or give meaning to?
The effects of difficult experiences may, however, emerge in the form of symptoms, bodily reactions, difficulties talking about what happened, or relational patterns that affect the functioning of a family. The ways in which these phenomena have been explained have changed with the development of psychology.
Perhaps this is why rituals, stories, and the presence of other people have been so important in many cultures. When an experience exceeded a person’s capacity to name it or work through it alone, someone had to help take the first step.
Bibliography
Abraham, N., & Torok, M. (1994). The Shell and the Kernel: Renewals of Psychoanalysis. University of Chicago Press.
Bion, W. R. (1962). Learning from Experience. Heinemann.
Brown, L. J. (2012). Bion’s discovery of alpha function: Thinking under fire on the battlefield and in the consulting room. The International Journal of Psychoanalysis, 93(5), 1191–1214.
Field, G. (2002). Nights underground in darkest London: The Blitz, 1940–1941. International Labor and Working-Class History, 62, 11–49. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0147547902000194
Freud, S. (1917). Mourning and melancholia. In J. Strachey (Ed. & Trans.), The Standard Edition of the Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud (Vol. XIV, 1957, pp. 243–258). Hogarth Press.
Jones, E., Woolven, R., Durodié, B., & Wessely, S. (2004). Civilian morale during the Second World War: Responses to air raids reexamined. Social History of Medicine, 17(3), 463–479. https://doi.org/10.1093/shm/17.3.463
Jones, E. (2021). COVID-19 and the Blitz compared: Mental health outcomes in the UK. The Lancet Psychiatry, 8(8), 708–716. https://doi.org/10.1016/S2215-0366(21)00118-8
Merriam-Webster. (n.d.). The mythological origin of “panic.” Merriam-Webster. https://www.merriam-webster.com/wordplay/the-mythological-origin-of-panic
Pennebaker, J. W., & Seagal, J. D. (1999). Forming a story: The health benefits of narrative. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 55(10), 1243–1254.
Schauer, M., Neuner, F., & Elbert, T. (2011). Narrative Exposure Therapy: A Short-Term Treatment for Traumatic Stress Disorders (2nd rev. and expanded ed.). Hogrefe.
Silverman, G. S., Baroiller, A., & Hemer, S. R. (2021). Culture and grief: Ethnographic perspectives on ritual, relationships and remembering. Death Studies, 45(1), 1–8. https://doi.org/10.1080/07481187.2020.1851885
van der Hart, O., & Friedman, B. (1989). A reader’s guide to Pierre Janet on dissociation: A neglected intellectual heritage. Dissociation, 2(1), 3–16.
van der Kolk, B. A., & van der Hart, O. (1989). Pierre Janet and the breakdown of adaptation in psychological trauma. American Journal of Psychiatry, 146(12), 1530–1540.